Skip to Content

Pine-Sol Vs Murphy’s Oil Soap (The Definitive Guide)

Are you tired of constantly searching for the perfect hardwood floor cleaner but not sure where to start? Look no further! Today we are putting two of the biggest names in the game to the test – Pine-Sol and Murphy’s Oil Soap.

Which product reigns supreme when it comes to value, effectiveness, and sustainability? Let's dive in and see which one is the winner in the battle of Pine-Sol vs Murphy’s Oil Soap for all your hardwood floor cleaning needs.

Comparison

Cleaning Power

Ease of Use

Value for Money

Sustainability and Odor Fighting

Hardwood Floor Cleaner

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Pine-Sol Vs Murphy’s Oil Soap

Cleaning Power

When it comes to cleaning your hardwood floors, you want a product that can effectively remove stains and dirt without causing damage or leaving residue. That's why we're comparing Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap in terms of their cleaning power.

First, let's talk about surface-level cleaning. Pine-Sol is known for its strong scent and ability to cut through grease and grime. It's an all-purpose cleaner that can be used on a variety of surfaces, including hardwood floors. Murphy's Oil Soap, on the other hand, is specifically formulated for wood surfaces. It's designed to clean and nourish wood while also leaving a pleasant scent.

In terms of removing stains and dirt, both products do a fairly good job. Pine-Sol is particularly effective on tough stains like grease and oil. However, it's important to note that Pine-Sol is a harsher cleaner and may strip the finish on your hardwood floors if used too frequently. Murphy's Oil Soap is gentler and won't damage your floors, but it's not as effective on tough stains.

When it comes to deep cleaning, both Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap can do the job. However, Murphy's Oil Soap has a unique ingredient called pure vegetable oil soap that helps to condition and protect your hardwood floors. This makes it an ideal choice for deep cleaning and maintaining the appearance of your floors over time.

Overall, whether you choose Pine-Sol or Murphy's Oil Soap will depend on your specific cleaning needs. If you're looking for a strong all-purpose cleaner that can tackle tough stains, Pine-Sol is a good choice. But if you want a gentler cleaner that will protect and nourish your hardwood floors, Murphy's Oil Soap is the way to go.

Ease of Use

When it comes to cleaning hardwood floors, ease of use is probably one of the most important factors to consider. After all, who wants to spend hours on their hands and knees applying and scrubbing just to get their floors looking clean and shiny? In this section, we will be taking a close look at how Pine-Sol and Murphy’s Oil Soap stack up when it comes to ease of use.

Starting with ease of application, both Pine-Sol and Murphy’s Oil Soap are pretty straightforward. They both come in liquid form and can be applied using a bucket and mop or a spray bottle. Pine-Sol's bottle, however, has a handle that makes it slightly easier to carry around your home and pour into containers.

One thing that sets these two products apart is the need for rinsing. Murphy’s Oil Soap requires rinsing after application, which can be a bit of a hassle. Pine-Sol, on the other hand, doesn’t require rinsing. This means you can apply it to your floors, and let it do its job without the need to rinse off any residue afterward.

When it comes to drying time, both products are relatively quick. Floors can be walked on within a matter of minutes after using either product. However, Pine-Sol dries just a little bit faster than Murphy’s Oil Soap, giving it a slight edge in this category.

Last but not least, let's talk packaging. Both products come in plastic bottles that are easy to pour, but there is a significant difference in the size of the containers. Pine-Sol comes in larger bottles, which might be more convenient if you’re trying to get a lot of cleaning done at once. On the other hand, Murphy’s Oil Soap bottles are smaller, making them easier to store in tight spaces.

In conclusion, both Pine-Sol and Murphy’s Oil Soap are relatively easy to use on hardwood floors, with some minor differences. Pine-Sol is slightly easier to apply, doesn’t require rinsing, and dries a bit faster. Meanwhile, Murphy’s Oil Soap has a smaller bottle that’s easier to store, but requires rinsing after application. Ultimately, the decision between these two products will likely come down to your individual preferences and needs.

Value for Money

When it comes to cleaning products, we all want to make sure we're getting the best value for our money. After all, nobody wants to shell out big bucks for a floor cleaner that doesn't actually get the job done.

In the battle of Pine-Sol vs. Murphy's Oil Soap, the value for money factor is definitely worth considering. Pine-Sol tends to be slightly less expensive than Murphy's, although prices can vary depending on where you purchase the products.

But it's not just about the initial cost - we also need to consider how long the product will last, and how often it needs to be used in order to keep hardwood floors clean. Some people find that they need to use more Pine-Sol than Murphy's in order to achieve the same level of cleanliness, which can ultimately end up costing more in the long run.

That being said, Pine-Sol does offer some value for money when it comes to its versatility - it can be used on a variety of surfaces, not just hardwood floors. So if you're looking for a multi-purpose cleaner, Pine-Sol might be the way to go.

Finally, it's always worth keeping an eye out for any discounts or special offers that might be available for either product. You never know when you might find a great deal that makes one product a better value than the other.

In conclusion, when it comes to value for money, Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap both have their pros and cons. Ultimately, it depends on your personal preferences and cleaning needs.

Sustainability and Odor Fighting

When it comes to keeping our homes clean, we all want to make sure we're doing it in a way that's eco-friendly and sustainable. That's why it's important to consider the impact our cleaning products have on the environment. In this section, we'll take a closer look at Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap to see how they measure up in terms of sustainability and odor fighting.

First, let's consider the impact of each product on the environment. Unfortunately, both products contain chemicals that can be harmful to the environment if not disposed of properly. However, Pine-Sol claims to be fully biodegradable, which means that it breaks down quickly and won't harm the environment. On the other hand, Murphy's Oil Soap does not make any claims about being biodegradable. So in terms of sustainability, Pine-Sol appears to be the better choice.

In terms of certifications, both Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap have received certifications that indicate they are eco-friendly. Pine-Sol has been certified by the EPA's Safer Choice program, which means that it has been rigorously tested and approved for its safety and sustainability. Murphy's Oil Soap, on the other hand, has been certified by Green Seal, a non-profit organization that sets environmental standards for products and services.

Now let's talk about odor fighting. Both products are marketed as effective at fighting tough odors, but is one better than the other? Based on customer reviews, it seems that Pine-Sol is generally more effective at tackling strong odors like pet urine or cigarette smoke. However, Murphy's Oil Soap may be better for everyday use in reducing mild odors.

So, when it comes to sustainability and odor fighting, it's a close call. While Pine-Sol appears to be more eco-friendly, both products have received certifications for their sustainability. And while Pine-Sol may be more effective at fighting strong odors, Murphy's Oil Soap is better for everyday use. In the end, it comes down to personal preference and what matters most to you.

Pine-Sol Vs Murphy’s Oil Soap Hardwood Floor Cleaner

When it comes to cleaning hardwood floors, there are two major brands that come to mind: Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap. Both brands offer a range of hardwood floor cleaners, but which one is better? Let's take a closer look at the offerings from each brand, using the reviewed products as examples.

Pine-Sol's Original Hardwood Floor Cleaner is a powerful cleaner that can disinfect and eliminate 99.9% of germs, including the COVID-19 virus and bacteria. This cleaner is perfect for those who want a long-lasting pine-scented cleaner that delivers a clean and fresh scent. Pine-Sol's cleaner is effective in removing tough bathroom soils such as soap scum, rust, and hard water, and can be used on a variety of surfaces including sinks, counters, and stoves. With its disinfecting power, Pine-Sol's Original Hardwood Floor Cleaner is a great choice for households with kids and pets.

On the other hand, Murphy's Oil Soap offers a more natural approach to hardwood floor cleaning with their Original Formula Oil Soap. Formulated with 98% natural ingredients, including water, coconut, and plant-derived cleaning agents, the Oil Soap is a gentle and eco-friendly cleaner that works well on wooden floors, furniture, cabinets, tile, and linoleum. The Oil Soap can also be used on other surfaces, leaving a natural shine and a pleasant fragrance. Murphy's Oil Soap has been trusted for over 100 years, making it a classic choice for those looking for a natural and reliable cleaner.

So, which brand is better? It all depends on your specific needs. If you want a powerful cleaner with disinfecting properties, Pine-Sol's Original Hardwood Floor Cleaner is the way to go. However, if you prefer a more natural approach with a long-standing reputation and don't mind the absence of disinfecting agents, Murphy's Oil Soap's Original Formula Oil Soap is ideal. Both brands offer great options for hardwood floor cleaning, so it's really a matter of personal preference.

Overall, when choosing between Pine-Sol and Murphy's Oil Soap, consider the specific attributes of the products offered by each brand. Whether you prioritize disinfecting power or eco-friendliness, both brands have a hardwood floor cleaner that can meet your needs.

PINE-SOL® ORIGINAL by Pine-Sol, powerful disinfectant with a refreshing pine scent.

PINE-SOL® ORIGINAL by Pine-Sol

Shop Check price on pinesol.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Powerful disinfectant with a refreshing pine scent.

What makes it special? PINE-SOL® ORIGINAL is a must-have for those who are looking for a powerful cleaner that can disinfect and eliminate 99.9% of germs, including the COVID-19 virus and bacteria. The #1 pine-scented dilutable cleaner is perfect for people who want to have a clean and refreshing scent that lasts longer. It is effective in cleaning and removing tough bathroom soils such as soap scum, rust, and hard water. You can use Pine-Sol® cleaners on different surfaces, including hardwood floors, sinks, counters, stoves, bathtubs, shower stalls, tile, and more. For best results, follow the directions on the label, and use the appropriate safety precautions before and during use. If you want a reliable cleaner that disinfects and has a fresh scent, PINE-SOL® ORIGINAL should be your top choice.

Find the best price on Pine-Sol

MURPHY® ORIGINAL FORMULA OIL SOAP by Murphy’s Oil Soap, reveal the natural beauty of your wood floors.

MURPHY® ORIGINAL FORMULA OIL SOAP by Murphy’s Oil Soap

Shop Check price on murphyoilsoap.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$+

Reveal the Natural Beauty of Your Wood Floors.

What makes it special? Murphy's Oil Soap has been trusted for over 100 years to safely and effectively clean wood floors to a natural shine. The Original Formula Oil Soap contains 98% natural ingredients, including water, coconut and plant-derived cleaning agents, and a natural fragrance, making it an eco-friendly choice. This versatile cleaner can also be used on furniture, cabinets, tile, and linoleum. For use on floors, simply dilute ¼ cup of the Oil Soap in a gallon of warm water, or ½ cup for heavy cleaning, and clean with a well-wrung mop – no rinsing required. Bring back nostalgia while cleaning with the same formula that Mom and Grandma used. Trust Murphy's Oil Soap to reveal wood's natural beauty.

Find the best price on Murphy’s Oil Soap

Final Verdict

In conclusion, Pine-Sol and Murphy’s Oil Soap are two great contenders when it comes to cleaning your hardwood floors. While both brands have their own set of unique features and benefits, one cannot be deemed better than the other. It ultimately depends on your personal preferences and cleaning needs.

If you’re on a budget and looking for a multipurpose cleaner that fights odors and stains, Pine-Sol may be the way to go. Their Original Pine scent has been a household favorite for decades, and their formula is tough on grime and dirt.

On the other hand, if you’re interested in a more natural option that’s gentle on your floors and sustainable, Murphy’s Oil Soap offers a plant-based solution that’s perfect for those looking for a greener cleaning alternative. Their original formula is infused with natural oils like coconut and lime, giving your floors a long-lasting shine.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. Whether you prefer the nostalgic scent of Pine-Sol or the eco-friendly approach of Murphy’s Oil Soap, both brands offer reliable and effective options for tackling dirty floors. So go ahead and choose the brand that works best for you, and let the cleaning begin!

Related articles

Fabuloso vs Pine Sol (The Definitive Guide)

Pine Sol vs Dettol (The Definitive Guide)

Pine Sol vs Simple Green (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Pine Sol vs Mr Clean (The Definitive Guide)

Pine Sol vs Pine Glo (The Definitive Guide)