Skip to Content

Bon Ami Vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Are you tired of scrubbing and scrubbing to get those stubborn stains out of your surfaces? You're not alone! When it comes to powder cleansers, there are two reigning brands on the market: Bon Ami and Comet. While both claim to be tough on dirt and grime, which one truly reigns supreme?

In this article, we'll dive deep into the similarities, differences, and unique features of these two popular powders to help you decide which one is right for your cleaning needs. So grab your goggles and let's get scrubbing!

Comparison

Brand History

Product Comparison

Safety and Environmental Impact

Price and Availability

Powder Cleanser

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Bon Ami Vs Comet

Brand History

To truly understand the differences between Bon Ami and Comet, we first need to look at the history behind both brands. Both of these cleaning products have been around for quite some time, and they both have their roots in different areas.

Starting with Comet, this product was first launched by the American Cyanamid company in 1956. At the time, it was marketed as a powder cleanser that could be used for nearly everything, from cleaning dishes to scrubbing toilets. One of the key features of Comet is its abrasive texture, which is designed to help break down dirt and grime quickly. Today, Comet is still owned by the same parent company, but it has evolved to become a multifunctional cleanser that is much less abrasive than it used to be.

On the other side of the coin, we have Bon Ami, which has a much longer history. This brand first came onto the scene back in 1886, when it was created by J.T. Robinson, a young entrepreneur from Connecticut. Unlike Comet, Bon Ami was marketed as a gentler, more natural option for cleaning, with the tagline "Hasn't scratched yet!" This was a reference to the fact that Bon Ami uses natural, non-abrasive ingredients like feldspar and limestone to clean without damaging surfaces.

Over the years, both of these brands have maintained their original missions and values, but they have evolved with the times to meet the needs of modern consumers. While Comet is still known for its tough cleaning power, the brand has also expanded with new products like sprays and gels that are designed for more specific cleaning tasks. Meanwhile, Bon Ami has remained committed to using natural ingredients, but it has also made changes to its packaging and marketing to appeal to a wider audience.

Ultimately, the history behind both of these brands is what sets them apart today. While Comet has a more recent origin story, it has built a reputation for being a reliable choice for tough cleaning jobs. Meanwhile, Bon Ami's long-standing commitment to gentle, natural ingredients has made it a trusted option for generations of households.

Product Comparison

When it comes to tackling household cleaning duties, few products are as dependable as Bon Ami and Comet powders. But which one should you choose? Let's take a closer look at their differences to help you make an informed decision about which product is best for your home.

First, let's discuss the ingredients. Bon Ami powder is made with natural, non-toxic ingredients like feldspar and limestone, while Comet powder contains harsher chemicals like bleach and soda ash. If you're someone who prefers eco-friendly products, Bon Ami might be the way to go. However, if you're dealing with tough stains and need something with a bit more cleaning power, Comet might be the better option.

Next, let's talk about scent. Bon Ami has a subtle, natural scent, while Comet has a more distinct, chemically smell. If you're sensitive to strong scents or prefer something a bit more pleasant, then Bon Ami might be the way to go.

Finally, let's look at how these powders perform on surfaces like sinks, toilets, and tubs. Both products have a similar texture and are abrasive enough to tackle grime and stains. However, some users have reported that Bon Ami is gentler on surfaces and less likely to scratch delicate finishes. On the other hand, Comet tends to be more effective at removing stubborn stains and buildup.

In the end, the choice between Bon Ami and Comet comes down to personal preference. If you're looking for a natural, eco-friendly option that's gentle on surfaces and has a subtle scent, then Bon Ami might be the right choice for you. However, if you need something with a bit more cleaning power to tackle tough stains and buildup, Comet might be a better fit. Whichever product you choose, you can rest assured that both Bon Ami and Comet are reliable choices for keeping your home clean and tidy.

Safety and Environmental Impact

When you're tackling tough stains and grime around your home, you want to make sure that the cleaning products you're using are safe for both you and the environment. In the case of Bon Ami and Comet powder cleaners, assessing their potential health risks and environmental impact is a crucial step in deciding which brand is right for you.

Let's start with the potential health risks. Both Bon Ami and Comet contain sodium bicarbonate, which is generally considered safe for use in cleaning products. However, Comet also contains sodium dichloroisocyanurate, a chlorine-based compound that can be toxic if ingested. If you have young children or pets in your home, you may want to be cautious about using Comet and ensure that it is stored securely out of their reach.

In terms of environmental impact, Bon Ami is often considered to be the more eco-friendly option. While both brands contain chemicals, Bon Ami uses fewer of them and is certified as biodegradable. Bon Ami also uses recycled materials in its packaging, which can reduce waste and help you to make a more sustainable choice for your home.

Ultimately, the choice between Bon Ami and Comet will depend on your individual priorities and concerns. If you're looking for a more natural, environmentally-friendly option, Bon Ami may be the way to go. However, if you have tough stains and need a powerful cleaner, Comet might be the better choice. Whatever decision you make, it's always a good idea to read the labels carefully and use these products safely to protect both yourself and the planet.

Price and Availability

When it comes to household cleaning products, it's important to not only consider their effectiveness but also their price and availability. Bon Ami and Comet are two popular powder cleansers that are often compared for their cleaning abilities. In this section, we will dive into how their prices and availability compare and help you determine which one offers the best value for your money.

First off, let's talk about price. Bon Ami is generally more expensive than Comet, but it's important to note that it typically comes in a larger container. A 14-ounce container of Bon Ami costs around $2.50, while a 21-ounce container of Comet costs around $1.50. However, since Bon Ami is a more natural and eco-friendly option, some consumers are willing to pay a little more for it.

Now let's discuss availability. Both Bon Ami and Comet are widely available in stores and online. You can find them at most grocery stores, big-box retailers, and online retailers such as Amazon. The availability of these products may vary depending on your location, but generally, they should be easy to find.

Occasionally, there are promotions and discounts available for both products. For example, you may find a coupon for Comet in your local newspaper or receive a discount through a loyalty program at your grocery store. Always be on the lookout for these deals to maximize your savings.

Overall, both Bon Ami and Comet offer great value for your money when it comes to cleaning power. When choosing between the two, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and priorities. If you're looking for a more eco-friendly option and don't mind paying a little extra, Bon Ami is the way to go. But if you're on a tight budget and want a reliable, affordable option, Comet will get the job done.

Bon Ami Vs Comet Powder Cleanser

When it comes to powder cleansers, two of the most popular brands on the market are Bon Ami and Comet. Both brands offer quality products with varying features and benefits. In this article, we will compare and contrast the two brands' offerings, using the reviewed products, Bon Ami Powder Cleanser and Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz, as examples to represent the range available from each brand.

Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is a natural, family-safe alternative to harsh chemical cleansers. With a formula made from only five simple, biodegradable ingredients, this product is gentle on skin and tough on stains. The hypoallergenic, glove-free cleaning solution uses natural soft abrasives that won't scratch surfaces. Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is eco-friendly, absorbing odors, and includes packaging that is made of 65% post-consumer recycled material and is fully recyclable. With a variety of compatible surfaces, Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is a popular household favorite suitable for many non-decorative hard surfaces.

In contrast, Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz provides a non-abrasive approach for all your cleaning needs. This all-purpose cleanser now has 50% More Cleaning Power than the original Comet Cleanser! This product is easy to use, simply sprinkle on wet surface or sponge, let sit, rub, and rinse. The Pine scent is the most popular, leaving your home with the fresh smell of clean. It's also available in Lavender and Lemon scents. It cleans and deodorizes porcelain, stainless steel, fiberglass, Corian® solid surfaces, natural marble, and glazed ceramic tile without scratching.

One of the primary differences between the two brands is that Bon Ami emphasizes its natural, biodegradable ingredients, while Comet focuses on its cleaning power. Bon Ami is a hypoallergenic cleaner that uses mild minerals and biodegradable cleaning agents, while Comet uses a combination of ingredients to create a powerful cleaning solution. Bon Ami is safe, non-toxic, and effective on a variety of surfaces, making it an excellent choice for families, while Comet offers a wide range of versatile cleaning solutions that are perfect for tough cleaning jobs.

Another difference between the two brands is their packaging. Bon Ami Powder Cleanser contains 65% post-consumer recycled material and is fully recyclable, while Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz comes in a traditional plastic container. Both brands offer a variety of sizes and scents to choose from, so consumers can find the product that best suits their needs.

In conclusion, Bon Ami and Comet are both quality brands with different strengths. Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is a natural, family-safe cleaner suitable for many non-decorative hard surfaces. It is eco-friendly, hypoallergenic, and gentle on skin. Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz, on the other hand, is a powerful all-purpose cleaner that can tackle tough cleaning jobs. It is available in a variety of scents and is compatible with several surfaces. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of the consumer when deciding between the two brands.

BON AMI POWDER CLEANSER 14 OZ. by Bon Ami, natural, tough-on-stains powder cleanser for family-safe cleaning.

BON AMI POWDER CLEANSER 14 OZ. by Bon Ami

Shop Check price on bonami.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Natural, tough-on-stains powder cleanser for family-safe cleaning.

What makes it special? Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is a natural, family-safe alternative to harsh chemical cleansers. With a formula made from only five simple, biodegradable ingredients, no chlorine, phosphorus, perfume, or dye, this product is gentle on skin and tough on stains. The hypoallergenic, glove-free cleaning solution uses natural soft abrasives that won't scratch surfaces, making it safe to use on everything from countertops and cookware to porcelain, enamel, fiberglass, and acrylic. Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is eco-friendly, absorbing odors, and includes packaging that is made of 65% post-consumer recycled material and is fully recyclable. With 14 oz and 21 oz sizes available, Bon Ami Powder Cleanser is a popular household favorite suitable for many non-decorative hard surfaces.

Find the best price on Bon Ami

Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz by Comet, powerful cleanser for tough household cleaning.

Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz by Comet

Shop Check price on cometcleaner.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Powerful cleanser for tough household cleaning.

What makes it special? Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz is a great all-purpose cleanser that provides a non-abrasive approach for all your cleaning needs. With 50% more cleaning power than the original Comet Cleanser, it's perfect for use on porcelain, stainless steel, fiberglass, Corian® solid surfaces, natural marble, and glazed ceramic tile without scratching. The Pine scent is the most popular, leaving your home with the fresh smell of clean. It's also available in Lavender and Lemon scents. This product is easy to use, simply sprinkle on wet surface or sponge, let sit, rub, and rinse. If the problem remains, let stand for 1 minute. It's important to note that this product should not be used on delicate surfaces like plastic, imitation marble, and appliance enamel and should not be mixed with other products, especially toilet bowl cleaners or products that contain ammonia. Overall, Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz is an effective and versatile product that should be considered for all your cleaning needs.

Find the best price on Comet

Final Verdict

In conclusion, when it comes to selecting a powder cleanser for your cleaning needs, both Bon Ami and Comet are excellent options. While Comet is known for its powerful cleaning capabilities and ability to tackle tough stains, Bon Ami offers a gentler yet effective cleaning experience that is suitable for everyday use.

Ultimately, which product you choose will depend on your personal preference and cleaning needs. If you're dealing with stubborn stains and grime, you might opt for Comet's tough formula. However, if you're looking for a powder cleanser that is gentle yet effective on a daily basis, Bon Ami might be the better choice.

No matter which product you select, it's important to keep in mind that both Bon Ami and Comet have a long-standing reputation for being reliable and effective cleaning solutions. So, whether you're tackling your kitchen sink or your bathroom tiles, you can rest assured that both of these brand's powder cleansers will get the job done.

Related articles

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Bon Ami (The Definitive Guide)

Ajax vs Bon Ami (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Ajax vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Biokleen vs Seventh Generation (The Definitive Guide)

Bon Ami vs Windex (The Definitive Guide)