Skip to Content

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Have you ever found yourself staring aimlessly at the endless options of cleaning products at your local supermarket? We've all been there! But when it comes to choosing between two popular powder cleansers - Bar Keepers Friend and Comet - the decision can be tough. Both products have a reputation for scrubbing away tough stains, but which one truly reigns supreme?

In this article, we're going to break down the key differences and similarities between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet, so you can make an informed decision before making that next purchase. So, let's get down and dirty with these cleaning products and see which one comes out on top!

Comparison

Ingredients and Formulation

Value for Money

Ease of Use and Effectiveness

Customer Satisfaction

Powder Cleanser

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Comet

Ingredients and Formulation

When it comes to cleaning products, understanding the ingredients and formulation can make a huge difference in their effectiveness. Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are both popular cleaning products, but what makes them different? Let's dive into the ingredients and formulation of each product to find out.

Bar Keepers Friend contains oxalic acid, a powerful cleaning agent that can remove rust, stains, and tarnish. It also contains surfactants, which help to break down dirt and grime. Unlike some other cleaning products, Bar Keepers Friend is non-abrasive and won't scratch surfaces. This makes it a great choice for cleaning delicate items like glassware or stainless steel appliances.

Comet, on the other hand, contains a variety of ingredients that work together to clean surfaces. It has bleach, which can whiten and disinfect surfaces, as well as various abrasives to help scrub away dirt and grime. However, the abrasives in Comet can be harsh and can scratch certain surfaces. It's important to be careful when using Comet on delicate materials.

So, what's the verdict? Bar Keepers Friend and Comet both have their strengths and weaknesses. If you're looking for a non-abrasive cleaner that can remove tough stains, Bar Keepers Friend is a great choice. On the other hand, if you need a powerful disinfectant and don't mind a little abrasiveness, Comet might be the way to go. Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to your cleaning needs and personal preferences.

Value for Money

When it comes to choosing cleaning products, it's important to consider the value you're getting for your money. In this section, we'll take a closer look at the value for money of Bar Keepers Friend and Comet.

First off, let's talk about quantity. Bar Keepers Friend is known for being a highly concentrated cleaner, meaning you only need a small amount to get the job done. On the other hand, Comet tends to require more product in order to achieve the same level of cleanliness.

In terms of pricing, Bar Keepers Friend is typically a bit more expensive than Comet. However, when you factor in the concentrated formula and the fact that it requires less product per use, the price difference starts to make more sense.

But what about quality? At the end of the day, it doesn't matter how much money you save if the product doesn't actually work. Luckily, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are effective cleaners. However, many people argue that Bar Keepers Friend does a better job at tackling tough stains and grime.

So, which product gives more value for money? Ultimately, it depends on your priorities. If you're looking for a budget option, Comet may be the way to go. However, if you value effectiveness and efficiency, investing in Bar Keepers Friend might be the better choice in the long run.

Ease of Use and Effectiveness

When it comes to cleaning your home, the last thing you want is a product that requires more effort and time. That's why we're comparing Bar Keepers Friend and Comet in terms of ease of use and effectiveness.

Let's start with ease of use. Both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet come in powder form that you need to sprinkle onto the surface you want to clean. You then add a bit of water to create a paste that you can scrub with a sponge or brush. Overall, the process is pretty straightforward and easy to understand.

However, some users have noted that Bar Keepers Friend is slightly easier to use because it has a finer, more uniform texture than Comet. This means that it's less likely to clump up or create lumpy patches on your surface. On the other hand, Comet can be a little harder to mix into a smooth paste, since it tends to be more granular.

Now let's talk about effectiveness. Both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are excellent at removing tough stains and grime. They are both popular choices for cleaning everything from sinks and stove tops to toilets and showers.

However, in terms of effectiveness, many people prefer Bar Keepers Friend. It contains more potent cleaning agents that can tackle even the toughest stains, such as rust, hard water stains, and grease. Plus, Bar Keepers Friend tends to be gentler on surfaces, so it won't scratch or damage delicate finishes.

On the other hand, some users have found that Comet needs to be used more frequently to achieve the same level of cleaning as Bar Keepers Friend. This is because Comet's cleaning agents are milder, which means it might not work as well on really stubborn stains. Plus, Comet can be more abrasive, so you need to be careful not to scrub too hard or you could damage your surfaces.

Overall, it's clear that both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are effective cleaning products that can get the job done. However, if you're looking for a product that requires less effort and time, and delivers more powerful cleaning results, Bar Keepers Friend wins in both categories!

Customer Satisfaction

When it comes to household cleaners, customer satisfaction is key. That's why we decided to take a closer look at Bar Keepers Friend and Comet to see how they stack up in terms of customer reviews, ratings, and feedback.

After scouring through countless customer reviews, it's clear that both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are beloved by many. However, Bar Keepers Friend received slightly higher ratings and more positive feedback overall. Customers praised its ability to remove even the toughest stains and grime, while leaving surfaces looking shiny and new.

One recurring theme in customer feedback for Comet was its strong scent and tendency to leave behind a residue. However, some customers still swear by its cleaning power and affordability.

So, which product should you choose? It ultimately comes down to personal preference and what you value most in a cleaner. If you prioritise effective cleaning and a shiny finish, Bar Keepers Friend may be the better option for you. If you're looking for an affordable option that gets the job done, Comet may be the way to go.

It's important to note that every product has its pros and cons, and what works for one person may not work for another. But with a little research and weighing of options, you can make an informed decision on which cleaner is right for you.

Bar Keepers Friend Vs Comet Powder Cleanser

When it comes to powdered cleansers, Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are two well-known brands that offer different products to clean different surfaces. Both of these brands' products have been in use for years, and they have been updated to cater to a wider range of needs. The products are made with different formulas and are suitable for different surfaces, so choosing between them depends on what you are looking for.

Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser is ideal for a range of non-porous surfaces, including glass, stainless steel, bronze, and aluminum. It is a tough but gentle solution that can remove stubborn rust, grease, water spots, and mineral deposits. The cleanser is versatile and can be used both indoors and outdoors. It is perfect for sinks, cookware, stovetops, countertops, porcelain or ceramic dishes, and toilets, among others.

On the other hand, Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz is ideal for different surfaces, including porcelain, stainless steel, fiberglass, Corian® solid surfaces, natural marble, and glazed ceramic tile without scratching. It has 50% more cleaning power than the original Comet Cleanser and is suitable for removing stains and deodorizing surfaces. It comes in different scents, including Pine, Lavender, and Lemon.

While both products are abrasive, Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser has finer abrasive particles, making it a better option for delicate surfaces. Comet Cleanser Pine, however, is not suitable for polished surfaces like marble and granite. When it comes to applying the cleansers, Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser requires less effort, while Comet Cleanser Pine requires a bit more elbow grease.

Another factor to consider when choosing between the two brands is their ingredients. Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser contains Glass Oxide Abrasive, Oxalic Acid, and Surfactant, while Comet Cleanser Pine contains Calcium Carbonate, Sodium Carbonate, Alkylbenzene Sulfonic Acid, and Trichloroisocyanuric Acid.

In conclusion, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet offer effective solutions for various cleaning needs, but choosing one ultimately depends on the surface you want to clean. Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser is perfect for non-porous surfaces, while Comet Cleanser Pine is suitable for surfaces like porcelain, stainless steel, natural marble, and glazed ceramic tile. Take into consideration the features mentioned above and choose the one that best fits your cleaning needs.

Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend , powerful and gentle cleaning solution for tough stains.

Cleanser by Bar Keepers Friend

Shop Check price on amazon.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Powerful and gentle cleaning solution for tough stains.

What makes it special? Bar Keeper's Friend Cleanser is the perfect cleaning solution for tough stains on non-porous surfaces. Its powerful formula is tough enough to remove stubborn rust and grease, yet gentle enough to use on glass and uncoated stainless steel and porcelain. The versatility of this product is unmatched, making it suitable for use in many different areas, such as kitchens, bathrooms, and outdoors. Although this powdered cleanser is not recommended for polished stone surfaces or painted and mirrored surfaces, it works wonders on sinks, cookware, stove tops, faucets, tiles, grills, sporting equipment, and more. On top of all that, Bar Keeper's Friend Cleanser is easy to use and delivers quick results. If you want to tackle tough stains with minimal effort, Bar Keeper's Friend Cleanser is the product for you.

Find the best price on Bar Keepers Friend

Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz by Comet, 50% more cleaning power in a fresh pine scent.

Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz by Comet

Shop Check price on amazon.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

50% more cleaning power in a fresh pine scent.

What makes it special? Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz is an all-purpose cleanser that guarantees 50% more cleaning power than the original Comet Cleanser. It comfortably cleans and deodorizes a range of surfaces, including porcelain, stainless steel, fiberglass, Corian® solid surfaces, natural marble, and glazed ceramic tile without scratching. The Pine scent is the most popular and will leave your home smelling fresh and clean. The cleanser provides a non-abrasive approach to all your cleaning needs, making it perfect for delicate surfaces like plastic, imitation marble, and appliance enamel. Just sprinkle Comet on a wet surface or sponge, let it sit for 15 seconds, rub, and rinse. However, if the problem persists, let the surface be for one minute before cleaning and rinsing. Comet Cleanser Pine - 21oz is a perfect solution for all your domestic cleaning needs.

Find the best price on Comet

Final Verdict

In conclusion, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are excellent choices when it comes to powder cleansers. They each have their own strengths and weaknesses, and it ultimately depends on your personal preferences.

For those looking for a more affordable option, Comet may be the way to go. It still does a great job of cleaning and can be found at most grocery stores for a lower price point.

However, for those who prioritize effectiveness and don't mind paying a bit more, Bar Keepers Friend may be the better option. Its unique formula and versatility make it a reliable and efficient product for various cleaning tasks.

Ultimately, it's important to consider what you need in a cleaner. If you're looking for a quick and easy solution for your basic cleaning needs, Comet may be the better choice. If you have tougher stains and need a reliable, effective product that can handle multiple surfaces, Bar Keepers Friend is definitely worth considering.

Regardless of which product you choose, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are reliable and effective options for cleaning with powder cleansers. So, whichever one you choose, you can trust that your cleaning needs will be met. Happy cleaning!

Related articles

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Ajax (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Bon Ami (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Brasso (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Soft Scrub (The Definitive Guide)

Ajax vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Bon Ami vs Comet (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Cif (The Definitive Guide)

Bar Keeper's Friend vs Gumption (The Definitive Guide)