Skip to Content

409 Vs Simple Green (The Definitive Guide)

Are you tired of using cleaning products that promise the world but underdeliver? Want to know which brand is truly worthy of your hard-earned money? Look no further, as we dive deep into the age-old battle between 409 and Simple Green. From environmental impact and ingredients to overall effectiveness and value for money, we've got it all covered. So grab a cup of coffee, sit back, and prepare to be enlightened. This is the showdown you didn't know you needed.



Environmental Impact

Value for Money


All-Purpose Cleaner

Final Verdict

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

409 Vs Simple Green

Effectiveness: Does 409 or Simple Green Clean Better?

When it comes to tough stains and grime buildup, it can be tough to find a cleaning solution that truly gets the job done. That's why many people turn to popular cleaning brands like 409 and Simple Green for their cleaning needs. But which brand is more effective when it comes to cleaning various surfaces and types of stains?

To begin, let's consider 409. This brand is known for its powerful formula that can tackle even the toughest of messes, from grease and oil stains to soap scum and mildew. One of the benefits of 409 is that it's incredibly easy to use – simply spray the solution onto the surface, let it sit for a few seconds, and then wipe away with a cloth or paper towel. This makes it a popular choice for quick and easy cleaning tasks.

On the other hand, Simple Green is a versatile cleaning solution that can be used on a wide range of surfaces, including glass, metal, and plastic. It's known for its gentle yet effective formula that can remove dirt, grime, and stains without causing damage or discoloration. One of the benefits of Simple Green is that it's also an eco-friendly option, made with plant-based ingredients that are safe for both people and the planet.

So, which brand should you choose? The answer ultimately depends on your specific cleaning needs. If you're looking for a powerful solution that can tackle tough stains quickly and easily, 409 may be the better choice for you. However, if you're looking for a versatile cleaning solution that's safe for a variety of surfaces and made with eco-friendly ingredients, Simple Green may be the way to go.

Overall, both 409 and Simple Green are effective cleaning solutions that can help keep your home looking and feeling clean. By considering factors such as ease of use, time required, and overall results, you can determine which brand is more effective for your needs and cleaning preferences.

Environmental Impact: Which Brand is More Eco-Friendly?

When considering which cleaning products to use in our homes, it's important to think about the impact they have on the environment. While both 409 and Simple Green are popular cleaning brands, they differ in their eco-friendliness.

Let's start with biodegradability. Simple Green is a plant-based cleaning solution that is fully biodegradable. This means that it will break down naturally over time without harming the environment. On the other hand, 409 isn't marketed as a biodegradable product, so it may have a more negative impact on the environment.

Toxicity is another factor worth considering. Simple Green produces a low level of toxicity when compared to 409. This means that it's less harmful to you and the environment if accidentally ingested or inhaled. It's also important to note that Simple Green is free from harmful chemicals, making it a safer option for those with allergies or sensitivities.

Finally, when it comes to sustainability, Simple Green is the clear winner. The brand uses sustainable ingredients that are responsibly sourced and environmentally friendly. In contrast, 409 may not use sustainable ingredients and could potentially contribute to environmental damage.

In conclusion, while both 409 and Simple Green are effective cleaning products, Simple Green is the more eco-friendly choice. With its biodegradable and sustainable formula, it's a safer and greener option that you can feel good about using in your home.

Value for Money: Which Brand Offers Better Value?

When it comes to household cleaners, there are plenty of options on the market. And if you're anything like me, you're always on the lookout for a product that can deliver great results without breaking the bank. That's where comparing the cost and value of brands like 409 and Simple Green comes in.

Let's start with price per ounce. At most retailers, both brands are similarly priced, with 409 typically costing a bit less. However, when it comes to overall effectiveness, Simple Green has a bit of an edge. It tackles tough stains and grime in a way that 409 sometimes struggles to match.

Of course, effectiveness is just one part of the equation. The other factor to consider is longevity - how long will a single bottle of cleaner last you? In our tests, we found that Simple Green tends to go further than 409. This means that you'll need to buy new bottles less frequently and ultimately save money in the long run.

So when it comes to the question of which brand offers better value, the answer is a bit of a mixed bag. While 409 is the more affordable option, Simple Green delivers better results and tends to last longer. Ultimately, the decision comes down to your individual cleaning needs and budget. But armed with the knowledge of these factors, you can make an informed purchase that leaves both your home and your wallet feeling clean and happy.

Ingredients: What is in 409 and Simple Green?

When it comes to cleaning products, it's important to know what's inside the bottle. After all, you're using these products to clean your home, and you want to make sure that you're not exposing yourself or your family to harmful chemicals. That's why we're taking a closer look at the ingredients in 409 and Simple Green.

First, let's talk about 409. This all-purpose cleaner contains a number of ingredients, including sodium hydroxide, which is a highly caustic substance that can cause chemical burns and respiratory problems if inhaled. It also contains a number of synthetic fragrances and dyes, which can be problematic for individuals with allergies or sensitivities.

On the other hand, Simple Green is known for its more eco-friendly ingredients. Its flagship product, Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner, is made primarily from water, plant-based surfactants, and natural solvents. It contains no phosphates, bleach, or ammonia, and is free from harmful toxins like chlorine and formaldehyde.

Of course, it's not just about what ingredients are present. We also need to consider how the ingredients are sourced and manufactured. Simple Green has a strong commitment to sustainability and uses renewable resources in its products whenever possible. In addition, the company has made efforts to reduce its carbon footprint and waste output.

When it comes down to it, the choice between 409 and Simple Green is largely a matter of personal preference. If you're looking for a more eco-friendly option that still gets the job done, then Simple Green is likely a better choice. However, if you have specific cleaning needs or preferences, you may find that 409 is a better fit for your home. Regardless of which product you choose, be sure to read the label carefully and follow instructions for safe use.

409 Vs Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner

When it comes to all-purpose cleaners, two of the most well-known and widely used brands are 409 and Simple Green. Both offer a range of cleaning solutions that aim to tackle tough stains and dirt, but while they may seem similar on the surface, there are some key differences that set them apart. To help you decide which brand is right for you, we’ve compared their offerings using the reviewed products as examples.

Starting with 409, their Multi-Surface Cleaner is a popular choice thanks to its powerful cleaning abilities and its ability to kill 99.9% of germs. This cleaner is available in two scents, Original and Lemon, and can be used on a range of surfaces and objects. The Smart Tube technology allows you to spray every last drop, ensuring you get the most out of each bottle. With a variety of sizes available, you can choose the option that best suits your needs. Simple Green, on the other hand, offers an All-Purpose Cleaner that is safe, non-toxic, and biodegradable. It has been approved by the EPA Safer Choice program, and is a concentrated cleaner that can be custom-diluted to tackle different tasks. Simple Green’s cleaner is also safe to use on different surfaces and items, from floors and walls to laundry and greasy tools, and it effectively removes a range of stains and dirt. With a sassafras mint fragrance, it leaves a pleasant and refreshing scent. When comparing the two products, it's clear that both offer powerful cleaning abilities, but there are some differences to consider. While 409 offers a range of sizes and two scent options, Simple Green offers a non-toxic, environmentally friendly solution that is approved by a reputable program. Simple Green also offers the customization of dilution strength, allowing the user to tailor the product to each task at hand. Additionally, Simple Green products are concentrates and provide a significant environmental benefit in terms of shipping costs. Ultimately, the decision between 409 and Simple Green may come down to personal preference. If you’re looking for a powerful cleaner with various size options and a stronger focus on germ-killing, 409 may be the better option. However, if you prioritize environmental safety and want a product that can be tailored to specific cleaning tasks, Simple Green may be the way to go. With both options available, it's never been easier to find the perfect All-Purpose Cleaner for your needs.

Formula 409® Multi-Surface Cleaner by 409, the ultimate all-purpose grease and dirt destroyer.

Formula 409® Multi-Surface Cleaner by 409

Shop Check price on

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

The ultimate all-purpose grease and dirt destroyer.

What makes it special? Looking for a tough all-purpose cleaner? Look no further than Formula 409® Multi-Surface Cleaner by 409. This hardworking cleaner takes care of kitchen grease and almost anything else. With its Smart Tube® technology, you can spray every last drop, making sure nothing goes to waste. Whether you choose Original or Lemon scent, you can be confident that it will kill 99.9% of germs† with every wipe. This versatile cleaner can be used on surfaces like stainless steel, tile, and even painted wood, as well as on items like pet areas and sports equipment. Available in various sizes and forms, Formula 409® Multi-Surface Cleaner is the perfect choice for anyone looking for a powerful and reliable cleaner.

Find the best price on 409

Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner 946ml - Recognized by the EPA Safer Choice program by Simple Green, a safe and powerful all-purpose cleaner.

Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner 946ml - Recognized by the EPA Safer Choice program by Simple Green

Shop Check price on

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

A Safe and Powerful All-Purpose Cleaner.

What makes it special? If you are searching for a multi-purpose cleaner that is safe, powerful, and long-lasting, Simple Green All-Purpose Cleaner could be the perfect solution. Approved by the EPA Safer Choice program, it has a non-toxic, biodegradable formula that tackles a wide range of tough stains, grime, grease, and oil, as well as pet messes, red wine spills, and even adhesives. Simple Green’s concentrated formula is customizable for all your cleaning needs, providing exceptional value for your money. This all-purpose cleaner can be used on almost any washable surface and has a subtle sassafras mint fragrance. Simple Green uses a unique microscopic system to break down oil, grease, and fat, resulting in thorough, powerful, and effective cleaning. Choosing Simple Green, you can expect an eco-friendly, quality product that truly delivers, all for an affordable price.

Find the best price on Simple Green

Final Verdict

In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between 409 and Simple Green for your cleaning needs, it really comes down to personal preference. Both brands have their unique advantages and disadvantages that should be considered. While 409 is great for tackling tough grease and grime, Simple Green offers an eco-friendly option for those who want to reduce their carbon footprint.

When it comes to overall satisfaction, users of both brands attest to their effectiveness in getting the job done. However, ingredients might be a dealbreaker for some consumers. If you prefer to use products with fewer harsh chemicals, Simple Green might be your choice. But if you're looking for a powerful cleaner that can handle the toughest messes, 409 will do the job.

In terms of value for money, both products are reasonably priced and will vary in cost, depending on the size and quantity. 409 is slightly more expensive, but it's a small price to pay for its powerful cleaning capabilities.

Ultimately, the choice between 409 and Simple Green comes down to your specific needs and preferences. Both brands offer value for money and effectiveness, but the final decision will depend on your individual priorities. Whether you prioritize cleaning power or eco-friendliness, 409 and Simple Green are both great choices that will get the job done. So go ahead and choose the one that suits your needs best, and enjoy a sparkling clean home or workspace!

Related articles

409 vs Lysol (The Definitive Guide)

Simple Green vs Fabuloso (The Definitive Guide)

Simple Green vs Krud Kutter (The Definitive Guide)

Simple Green vs Mean Green (The Definitive Guide)

Simple Green vs Superclean (The Definitive Guide)

Simple Green vs Zep (The Definitive Guide)

Read more

Rejuvenate vs Bona (The Definitive Guide)

Purple Power vs Simple Green (The Definitive Guide)